SOUL
| Angler | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
soul pole |
Cost of making green flourescent or L.E.D. lights |
Lead | ||
|
For all you light building pro's, I was wondering about the cost and availability of parts to make my own green lights. I have a couple of the cheap green flourescents that I bought from a baitshop in Titusville last year and they work great, but they are nowhere near the caliber of your lights. The thing is a hundred bucks is more than I can afford for one light. Is it worth it to build my own in terms of cost?? Thanks for your help!
SOUL |
||||
|
|
||||
NiteOwl40 |
#1 | |||
|
Jerry,
The professional type Fluorescent light you see out there are built as an www.ISAA.CC club project light, made once a year, usually in October. I have led to last 3 year's party, so I can speak from first hand knowledge. The last 2 years lights used an 18" bulb. The club buys parts in bulk and gets significant discounts for the quantity of lights built. To build one or 2 or 5 lights, you would have to pay about $90, and figure out how to put it all together into a watertight assembly. Not an easy task. There are no plans or instructions outside of ISAA. I am the originator/designer of the 18" greenies. I don't recommend this as your first light building venture. I know people that tried building them only to have them leak water and short out. I know people that have tried to imitate the green light with plastic film and household fluorescent bulbs and have everything look great prior to turning them on, and be disappointed with the results. Now, as far as LED technology goes, it also sounds simple. LED's have been around for years. But not all LED's are created equal, and thus far, there aren't any LED lights competitive with Fluorescent green lights. In fact, Engineering an LED light is new territory even for an Engineer. What you have seen on this message board is a Cutting Edge, first of a kind prototype light, that I will make as a startup business venture. Believe me when I tell you, Just the new technology LED's needed is a very expensive item. Making these lights is not a shoestring $operation. So, I'm telling you to be patient, save your money and buy one good light instead of several iterations of the cheaper lights sold in bait shops. Then, save some more for a second light. Lights are but one part of the equation for catching shrimp. Any light can be used to catch shrimp, but not all light types are equal, and it's light type and deployment complementing each other that will improve your catch. Location, Location, Location is another part. Type of net is a third part, Shrimp Biology is a fourth part. And so on. You've come to the right place for this information. Tell us what kind of shrimping and location you're doing - boat, sea wall, pier, or bridge dipping. We have all types on this board. Don't be shy or feel intimidated. Mosts of the members here also started out with little or no experience or no how, and there aren't any books yet about shrimping. |
||||
|
|
||||
soul pole |
#2 | |||
|
Thanks for the detailed response, I appreciate your time and knowledge. Oh well I guess that idea isn't gonna work, time to save my pennies...more ramen noodles and Keystone light ha!
About me, I mostly fish, but I have also been shrimping faithfully the last 10 years since coming back to Brevard from my duty station in Mayport, before that I went when I was a kid with my parents. I am in the Satellite Beach area and I shrimp all over the county from boats, bridges or wherever I can get 'em. I do fairly well, I travel north to Oak Hill in the late winter and early spring for quantity shrimping and come back down to this area for the big shrimp later in spring and summer. The whole green light thing is new to me since last year. Previously I used coleman lanterns and halogens. I find the green lights do improve the catch and don't drain the batteries. I would love one of the led lights you build, maybe by next year I can pick one up, they sure sound nice, I bet they look great in the water. I can't wait for it to warm up so we can see how good this year is really gonna get, I had a good year last year in comparison to the previous few, and am ready to get after em again. Thanks again! |
||||
|
|
||||
CaptLeeNoga |
#3 | |||
|
Great discussion!
I know folks will be selling off their fluorescent when they go LED. I know I will be selling mine for $75 each. Maybe others will sell for $65...but maybe think about saving and buying a used fluorescent vs. building. The trial and error of building a simplistic light can get expensive especially if there is a breach and the internals are exposed to salt water. Some other folks did some building TimmyB, maybe he can shed some more light..and share his costs for this LED he made. Frankk here has made his own fluorescents, Sleepless too. USCG Licensed [OUPV/6 pak] - Captain 100% Disabled Vet E-5/USN Medic |
||||
|
|
||||
timmyb |
#4 | |||
|
My LED lights are starting out kinda getto. I went and bought a LED drop light at the Home depot. It shines directional is a white LED. It has a built in battery charger but is also 12volts. So I cut the cigerette adapter off and put alligator clips on to attach to my battery. But a charge on the light itself last 4 hours. I then attach it to something I can stick deeper in the water. I did experiment Saturday night with a white on and the one I had already made before with part of a sprite bottle wrapped around it. It did take a lot of the glare off, as far as making it green, thumbs down on that one. I think I need to get actual green LED's to make that happen. I went to a seminar on LED lighting because I have to for work. There are so many ways to make them right now. The only problem is cost. The good lights will cost a lot at this point in time. The ones from Home Depot or Walmart are the cheap chinese ones and wont last as long or be as bright. But over time cost will come down. Almost forgot, My light cost me $20.00 and change, the pop bottle cost $2.00, the silicone for sealing many areas water could get in $5.50, the fun I had Friday and Saturday... PRICELESS
Last Edited By: timmyb 03/08/10 07:50 AM.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Sleepless |
Cost to make 2' greenies | #5 | ||
|
I built several 2' fluorescent greenines a little over a year ago. In fact, my excess lights, unused, are for sale and listed here in the appropriate forum. These are made to ISAA standards, in fact the same materials, but I had to pay the going price for all the parts since I did not qualify for quantity discounts. My total costs, including gasoline to pick up the parts and sales tax, was approximately $95.00 per light. That is the price I am selling them for.
Bob |
||||
|
|
||||